HELSINKI
COMMISSION CHIDES KHODORKOVSKY VERDICT AS ARBITRARY JUSTICE
(Washington) - The leadership of the U.S. Commission
on Security and Cooperation in Europe, (the U.S. Helsinki Commission),
expressed disappointment today at the nine-year long prison sentence
meted out to Russian oil magnate Mikhail Khodorkovsky by a court
in Moscow. The prosecution had sought the maximum ten- year sentence.
``This case appears to the world to be justice
directed by politics,`` said Commission Chairman Senator Sam Brownback
(R- KS). ``President Putin should keep in mind that basic human
rights, a fair and equitable judicial system, and real democracy
are the cornerstones of the true market reforms he professes--
anything less is a step backwards. It seems that, from the Kremlin`s
viewpoint, Khodorkovsky`s worst crime was that he crossed the
line between business and politics.``
The Commission on Security and Cooperation in
Europe, also known as the Helsinki Commission, is a U.S. Government
agency that monitors progress in the implementation of the provisions
of the 1975 Helsinki Accords. The Commission consists of nine
members from the United States Senate, nine from the House of
Representatives, and one member each from the Departments of State,
Defense and Commerce.
Khodorkovsky, one of Russia`s wealthiest persons
and former president of the YUKOS oil company, has been detained
since October 2003 and was sentenced on May 31 to nine years imprisonment
for fraud and tax evasion. During the investigatory stage of the
case, Khodorkovsky`s legal counsels charged that the government
illegally interfered with the conduct of their client`s defense.
Many political observers and human right activists
assert that Khodorkovsky`s financial transgressions were no worse
than the other ``oligarchs`` who cashed in on Russia`s fluid legal
system and dubious business practices after the collapse of the
Soviet Union. His real crime, they charge, is having become active
in political circles opposing President Vladimir Putin, and even
hinting he might run for political office.
``Selective prosecution such as appears to be
the case here will wreak havoc on Russia`s legal system, its democratic
development and its economic future,`` stated Commission Co-Chairman
Christopher H. Smith (R-NJ). ``If President Putin values Russia`s
future more than his own short-term political benefit, he needs
to look long and hard at his legal system.``
``This is not just about one individual,`` said
Commission House Ranking Member Benjamin L. Cardin (D-MD). ``Neither
genuine social stability nor long-term prosperity can be achieved
through arbitrary jurisprudence in any country. I urge Russian
officials to stop using the judiciary system to punish political
opponents.``